Union of Akashvani & Doordarshan (Prasar Bharati) Engineering Employees (UADEE

(Registered under Trade Union Act, 1926; Regn.No. 5135) 

Head Quarter : C-4 D/ 81 B, Janakpuri, New Delhi-110 058

visit our website: http://www.uadee.org

 

 

 

IMPORTANT   JUDGMENTS   OF   COURTS   IN    SERVICE    MATTERS

Sr. No.

COURTS

DATE OF JUDGMENTS

CASES

To View, Click 

A

Revision of Pay Scale of Sound Recordists of DD leading to revision of pay scales of EA OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN

01

SCI 26.08.1988 Judgment of Supreme Court in WP No.974/1978, 1239/1979 & 1756/1986 titled Y.K.Mehta v/s UOI Click here

02

SCI 12.04.1990 Judgment of Supreme Court in WP No.240/1989 titled DD CWA v/s UOI Click here
B
Revision of Pay Scale of EA OF AIR & DD consequent upon revision of pay scales of Sound Recordists of DD  

01

Background for Revision of Pay scales of Engineering Assistants of AIR & Doordarshan Click here

02

CAT,Madras

29.06.1990

Judgment of CAT, Madras Bench in OA No.654/1989 titled A. Rajasekaran v/s MIB & DGDD. Click here

03

SCI 07.01.1991 SLP filed by MIB before SCI against judgment dated 29.06.1990 of CAT, Madras Bench is dismissed on merits Click here

04

CAT,Madras 10.06.1992 Judgment of CAT, Madras Bench rescinding its judgment dated 29.06.1990 in Review Petition No.4 of OA No. 654 filed by UOI Click here

05

SCI 25.11.1994 Judgment of SCI upholding judgment dated 29.06.1990 of CAT, Madras Bench and thus giving finality to revision of scale of EA Click here
C
Revision of Pay Scale of SEA OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN consequent upon revision of pay scales of EA

01

Background for Revision of Pay scales of Sr. Engineering Assistants of AIR & Doordarshan Click here

02

CAT,Bangalore 16.02.2000 Judgment of CAT, Bangalore Bench in OA No.654/1989 titled A. Rajasekaran v/s MIB & DGDD. Click here

03

HC,Karnataka 14.02.2001 Judgment of Karnataka High Court in Writ Petitions No. judgment dated 29.06.1990 in Review Petition No.4 of OA No. 654 filed by UOI Click here

04

SCI 17.12.2001 Judgment of SCI upholding judgment dated 29.06.1990 of CAT, Madras Bench and thus giving finality to revision of scale of EA Click here
D

RECRUITMENT RULES - 1982 OF ASSISTANT ENGINEERS OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN

01

CAT, Delhi 31.12.1986 Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1982 is discriminatory & violative of Art.14 &16 of Constitution of India-Courts' Judgments  Click here

02

SCI 04.05.1987 Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1982 is discriminatory & violative of Art.14 &16 of Constitution of India-Courts' Judgments  Click here

03

SCI 10.08.1987 Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1982 is discriminatory & violative of Art.14 &16 of Constitution of India-Courts' Judgments  Click here
E

RECRUITMENT RULES - 1985 OF ASSISTANT ENGINEERS OF AIR & DOORDARSHAN

01

CAT, Delhi 03.05.1991 Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1985 is lawful and valid-Courts' Judgments  Click here

02

SCI 09.09.1997 Assistant Engineer Recruitment Rules, 1985 is lawful and valid-Courts' Judgments  Click here
F
JUDGMENTS  AGAINST/FOR  IB(E)S  AMENDMENT  RULES, 1989

01

Background - Degree holders cannot have preferential treatment in promotions at JTS level Click here

02

CAT,Lucknow 28.10.2002 Judgment of CAT, Lucknow Bench in OA No.218/1995 titled Romesh Chander Nadir & ors v/s UOI Click here

03

HC,Lucknow 24.10.2003 Judgment of High Court, Lucknow Bench in WP No.251/2003 titled UOI & ors v/s Romesh Chander Nadir & ors Click here

04

SCI 05.12.2003 Judgment of Supreme Court in SLP No.21643/2003 titled Romesh Chander Nadir & ors v/s UOI Click here

05

CAT,Cuttack 22.03.2004 Judgment of CAT, Cuttack Bench in OA No.538/1999 titled U.K.Sahoo & ors v/s UOI Click here
G
Revision of Pay Scale of Lighting Assistants of DD at par with Assistant Cameraman of FILMS IVISION

01

Background - Brief history of parity of pay scale between Lighting Assistants of DD and Assistant Cameraman of Film Division Click here

02

CAT, Delhi 15.05.2007 Judgment of CAT,New Dehi in Sanjeev Kumar's OA No.2386/2005, dated 15.05.2007 Click here

03

HC, Delhi 15.12.2010 Judgment of Delhi High Court in Govt's Writ Petition (C) No.6544/2007, dated 15.12.2010 Click here

04

CAT, Delhi 18.05.2012 Judgment of CAT,New Dehi in P. Satyanarayana Rao's OA No.1700/2012, dated 18.05.2012 Click here
H
Revision of Pay Scale of Tech. & Sr.Tech. OF AIR & DD consequent upon revision of pay scales of Lighting Assistants OF DD

01

Background - Brief history of revision of pay scale of Tech at par with Lighting Assistants of DD  Click here

02

CAT, Delhi 14.12.1999 Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in OA No.164/1996, dated 14.12.1999 in ARTEE's case NA

03

HC, Delhi 08.07.2011 Judgment of Delhi High Court in CWP No.3787/2000, dated 08.07.2011 in ARTEE's case Click here

04

SCI 02.09.2013 Judgment of Sup.Court in RP(Civil) No.2276/2012 in SLP(C) No.14381/2012,dated 02.09.2013 in ARTEE's case Click here

05

CAT,Chennai 10.07.2008 Judgment of CAT,Chennai Bench in OA No.390/2006, dated 10.07.2008 in ADTEA's case Click here

06

HC,Chennai 24.11.2010 Judgment of Chennai High Court in WP(C) No.27155/2009, dated 24.11.2010 in ADTEA's case Click here

07

SCI 10.01.2013  Judgment of Supreme Court in SLP(C) No.33048/2011,  dated 10.01.2013 in ADTEA's case Click here

08

CAT, Delhi 15.12.2014 Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in OA No.4424/2014 of ARTEE for pay scale of 5000-8000 to Tech at par with LA Click here

09

CAT, Delhi 01.04.2015 Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in OA No.1861/2014 of Ashok Kr Yadav for pay scale of 5000-8000 to Tech at par with LA Click here

10

CAT, Delhi 15.02.2016 Judgment of CAT, New Delhi in RA148/2015 in OA No.1861/2014 of Ashok Kr Yadav for PS of 5000-8000 to Tech at par with LA Click here
I

Grant of ACP AS RECOMMENDED BY 5TH CPC

Background - Reasons for admissibility and litigation with the Govt

Click here

01

CAT,Patna

07.09.2009

Order dated 07.09.2009 of CAT, Patna bench in OA No.514/2002 titled B.K.Roy & 11 others

Click here

02

HC, Patna

25.08.2010

Order dated 25.08.2010 of the Patna High Court in CWJC 6451/2010

Click here

03

SCI

10.01.2011

Order dated 10.01.2011 of the Supreme Court in CC No.20212/2010

Click here

04

MIB

29.06.2011

Order dated 29.06.2011 of Ministry of I&B along with comments of DOP&T, Ministry of Finance & Ministry of Law on grant of ACP 

Click here

05

MIB

04.11.2011

Order dated 04.11.2011 of Ministry of I&B declaring the petitioners of Patna as ineligible for ACP benefits on findings of Screening Committee

Click here

06

CAT,Patna

 08.12.2011

Interim order dated 08.12.2011 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002

Click here

07

MIB

03.01.2012

Minutes of 2nd Screening Committee of MIB dated 03.01.2012 vide No. 503/17/2011-BA(E) granting ACP to 08 petitioners of Patna

Click here

08

DGAIR

17.01.2012

Order dated 17.01.2012 of DGAIR on grant of ACP benefits to 08 petitioners of Patna

Click here

09

CAT,Delhi

01.02.2012

Order dated 01.02.2011 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 477/2011 of Praveen Kumar vs UOI

Click here

10

CAT,Patna

02.03.2012

Interim order dated 02.03.2012 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002

Click here

11

CAT,Patna

23.05.2012

Order dated 23.05.2012 of the Patna CAT in Contempt Petition CCPA No.22/2011 in OA No. 514/2002

Click here

12

CAT,Delhi

24.05.2011

Order dated 24.05.2011 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 597/2011 of DEEWA vs UOI (Total 23 applicants)

Click here

13

CAT,Delhi

09.10.2012 

Order dated 09.10.2012 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 3400/2012 of Vinod Kumar & Others vs UOI (Total 07 applicants)

Click here

14

CAT,Delhi

01.03.2013

Order dated 01.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in CP No. 710/2011 in OA No. 597/2011 of DEEWA vs UOI

Click here

15

CAT,Delhi

04.03.2013

Order dated 04.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 757/2013 of Umesh Chandra & 10 ors vs UOI vs UOI (Total 11 applicants)

Click here

16

CAT,Delhi

13.03.2013

Order dated 13.03.2013 of the Delhi CAT in OA No. 879/2013 of S.K.Mishra & ors vs UOI vs UOI (Total 07 applicants)

Click here

17

HC Patna

23.10.2013

Order dated 23.10.2013 of Patna High Court in Review Petition No. 141/2012 in OA No. 514/2002

Click here

18

CAT,Delhi

31.10.2013

Order dated 31.10.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 3106/2013 of Manoj Kumar Gupta vs UOI (Total 26 applicants)

Click here

19

CAT,Delhi

20.12.2013

Order dated 20.12.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 4439/2013 of Pradeep Gupta  vs UOI (Total 35 applicants)

Click here

20

CAT,Delhi

24.12.2013

Order dated 24.12.2013 of Delhi CAT in OA No. 4520/2013 of Pradeep Galhotra  vs UOI (Total 61 applicants)

Click here

21

CAT, Patna

31.01.2014

Order dated 31.01.2014 of CAT, Patna in OA No. 350/2013 of H.K.Mishra & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 03 applicants)

Click here

22

CAT, Delhi

03.03.2014

Order dated 03.03.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1147/2013 of Thomas Mathew & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 09 applicants)

Click here

23

Delhi HC 05.04.2014

Order dated 05.04.2014 of Delhi HC in WP No. 4618/2013 of N.Manjunath & Ors v/s UOI & Ors on grant of 2nd ACP to Sound Recordist in the Pay Scale of Rs 8000-13500.

Click here

24

CAT, Delhi 15.05.2014

Order dated 15.05.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 854/2014 of Y. P. Singh & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 177 applicants)

Click here

25

CAT, Delhi 09.10.2014

Order dated 09.10.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3580/2014 of Joginder Singh & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 16 applicants)

Click here

26

CAT, Delhi 15.10.2014

Order dated 15.10.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No.3675/2014 of MRC Reddy & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 23 applicants)

Click here

27

CAT, Delhi 14.11.2014

Order dated 14.11.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4028/2014 of A.K.Bhatnagar & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 99 applicants)

Click here

28

CAT, Delhi 01.12.2014

Order dated 01.12.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4249/2014 of ARTEE & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 04 applicants)

Click here

29

CAT, Delhi 03.12.2014

Order dated 03.12.2014 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4280/2014 of A.M.Sharma & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 43 applicants)

Click here

30

CAT, Delhi 19.01.2015

Order dated 19.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 215/2015 of S.K.Agrawal & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 154 applicants)

Click here

31

CAT, Delhi 28.01.2015

Order dated 28.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2591/2013 of Vinod Kr & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 7 applicants)

Click here

32

CAT, Delhi 28.01.2015

Order dated 28.01.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4191/2013 of Anil Kr Sharma & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 40 applicants)

Click here

33

CAT, Delhi

06.05.2015

Order dated 06.05.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 164/2014 of DEEWA & Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 8 applicants)

Click here

34

Patna HC 

12.05.2015

Order dated 12.05.2015 of Patna High Court in Writ Petition No. CWJC No.1869/2015 in OA No. 514/2002

Click here

35

CAT, Delhi 21.05.2015

Order dated 21.05.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 4462/2013 of UADEE & 92 Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 93 applicants)

Click here

36

Patna HC 

29.06.2015

Order dated 29.06.2015 of Patna High Court in Writ Petition No.CWJC No. 2797/2014 titled  N.K.Srivastava & 5 Ors 

Click here

37

CAT, Delhi 21.07.2015

Order dated 21.07.2015 of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2608/2015 of S.K.Singh & 73 Ors v/s UOI & Ors (Total 74 applicants)

Click here

38

CAT, Delhi 16.10.2015

Order dated 16.10.2015 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.68/2015 in OA No. 3580/2014 of Joginder.Singh & 15 Ors v/s UOI & Ors 

Click here

39

CAT, Delhi 18.11.2015

Order dated 18.11.2015 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.508/2015 in OA No. 215/2015 of Sushil Kumar Agarwal & Ors v/s UOI & Ors 

Click here

40

CAT, Delhi 10.03.2016

Order dated 10.03.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.357/2015 in OA No. 2591/2013 of Vinod Kumar  & 06 Ors v/s UOI & Ors 

Click here

41

CAT, Delhi 17.03.2016

Order dated 17.03.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.396 & 606 of 2014 in OA No.854/2014 of Y.P.Singh, CP No.673/2015 in OA No.2608/2015 of S.K.Singh  & CP. No. 664/2015 in OA No. 4462/2013 of UADEE (Total three CPs)

Click here

42

CAT, Delhi 

19.04.2016

Order dated 19.04.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.443/2015 in OA No.4191/2013 of Anil Kumar Sharma & 39 Ors vs UOI & Ors.

Click here

43

HC, Patna

13.07.2016

Order dated 13.07.2016 of the Patna High Court in Misc. Jurisdiction case No 2912/2015 in CWJC 2797/2014 of N.K.Srivastava

Click here

44

CAT, Delhi

21.07.2016

Order dated 21.07.2016 of CAT, Delhi in CP No.555/2015 in OA No. 164/2014 of 07 applicants of DEEWA v/s UOI & Ors 

Click here

45

Delhi  HC

13.07.2017

Delhi High Court allows ACP/MACP to PSA in upgraded scales of MIB's OM dated 25.02.1999

Click here

46

CAT, Delhi

08.08.2018

Delhi Judgment dated 08.08.2018 in OA No. 305/2015 titled Neeraj Tirkey & 115 others in grant od ACP

Click here
J

Grant of MACP AS RECOMMENDED BY 6TH & 7TH CPC

01

High Court 19.10.2011 Judgment of Chandigarh HC in CWP No.19387/2011 to give MACP in Promotional hierarchy - UOI vs Raj Pal        Click here

02

CAT, Delhi 26.11.2012 Order of CAT in OA No.904/2012 to give MACP to Defence Staff  in Promotional hierarchy         Click here

03

SCI 15.04.2013 Judgment of Supreme Court in CC No.7467/2013 to give MACP in Promotional hierarchy - UOI vs Raj Pal        Click here

04

CAT, Delhi 12.03.2014 Order of CAT in  OA No.864/2014 to give MACP to NCERT in Promotional hierarchy         Click here

05

CAT, Delhi 21.03.2014 Order of CAT in OA No.988/2014 to give MACP to CCW, AIR & DD, in Promotional hierarchy 

         Click here

06

Madras HC 04.02.2015 Judgment in WP No. 30629 of 2014: MACP to be granted ignoring promotion by LDCE- D. Sivakumar case

Click here

07

SCI 16.08.2016 Judgment in SLP(C) No. 4848 of 2016:  MACP to be granted ignoring promotion by LDCE- D. Sivakumar case

Click here

08

High Court

06.06.2017 /

20.12.17

Judgment in WP(C) No.9357/2017 : NFU in GP-5400 after 4 yrs service in GP-4800 in not countable in MACP - Hari Ram & others vs Registrar General of Delhi High Court       Click here

09

SCI 08.12.2017 Judgment in CA Diary No. 3744 of 2016:  MACP is admissible wef  01.01.2006 to Defence staff - UOI vs Balbir Singh Turn

Click here

10

MoD 25.07.2018 Order No.No.14\(1)/99-D(AG):  General order of implementation for all employees of MoD

Click here

11

Bombay HC 15.10.2018 Judgment in WP(C) No.1763 of 2013:  MACP is admissible wef 01.01.2006  - Case of M.P.Joseph

Click here

K

Grant of GRADE PAY OF Rs 5400 in PB-2 AFTER 4 YRS OF SERVICE IN GP-4800 AS PER 6TH CPC

 

01

HC

13.06.2010

Judgment of Madras High Court in WP(C) No. 13225/2010 in case of Central Excise Inspectors

   Click here

02

CAT

06.08.2010

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2662/2009 of R.K.Jain & 3 Others

 Click here

03

CAT

24.11.2010

Corrected Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2662/2009 of R.K.Jain & 3 Others

  Click here

04

CAT

17.04.2014

Judgment of CAT in RA No.12/2012 in OA No.2662/2009

Click here:

05

CAT

05.11.2014

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3048/12 of B.P.Dhaman & 1 Other

Click here

06

CAT

23.04.2015

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1515/2015 of Neeraj Choudhary & 14 Others

Click here

07

CAT

05.05.2015

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1667/2015 of S.K.Chaudhary & 46 Others

Click here

08

CAT

08.05.2015

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 1738/2015 of T.Purushan & 17 Others

Click here

09

CAT

12.08.2015

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 2949/2015 of Tribhuwan Pati & 34 Others

Click here

10

CAT

14.08.2015

Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3030/2015 of O.P.Rajpurohit & 22 Others

Click here

11

CAT

08.12.2016
Judgment of CAT, Delhi in OA No. 3541/2016 filed by ARTEE

Click here